Humanitext Reader

Justinian I · The Digest of Justinian §35.1.27.pr

Error in Monument Designation and Penalty on Heirs

Passage 5358 of 9271 · Latin

Summary

A jurist's response addressing the heirs' obligation to build a monument and the applicability of a penalty when the specific model designated in the will cannot be found due to a suspected clerical error.

[ALFENUS UARUS libro quinto digestorum. ] §35.1.27.prIn testamento quidam scribserat, ut sibi monumentum ad exemplum eius, quod in uia Salaria esset Publii Septimii Demetrii, fieret: nisi factum esset, heredes magna pecunia multare et cum id monumentum Publii Septimii Demetrii nullum repperiebatur, sed Publii Septimii Damae erat, ad quod exemplum suspicabatur eum qui testamentum fecerat monumentum sibi fieri noluisse, quaerebant heredes, cuiusmodi monumentum se facere oporteret et, si ob eam rem nullum monumentum fecissent, quia non repperirent, ad quod exemplum facerent, num poena tenerentur.
[ALFENUS VARUS, in the fifth book of his Digests.] In a will a certain person had written that a monument should be made for himself according to the model of that of Publius Septimius Demetrius which was on the Salarian Way; and that unless it were made, the heirs should be fined a large sum of money. And when no such monument of Publius Septimius Demetrius was found, but there was one of Publius Septimius Dama, under which model it was suspected that he who had made the will did not wish a monument to be made for himself, the heirs asked what kind of monument they ought to make, and whether, if they made no monument for that reason, because they could not find the model according to which they were to make it, they would be liable to the penalty.
respondit, si intellegeretur, quod monumentum demonstrare uoluisset is qui testamentum fecisset, tametsi in scriptura mendum esset, tamen ad id, quod ille se demonstrare animo sensisset, fieri debere: sin autem uoluntas eius ignoraretur, poenam quidem nullam uim habere, quoniam ad quod exemplum fieri iussisset, id nusquam exstaret, monumentum tamen omnimodo secundum substantiam et dignitatem defuncti exstruere debere.
He replied that if it could be understood which monument the person who had made the will had wished to point out, although there was an error in the writing, it ought nevertheless to be made according to that which he had intended in his mind to point out; but if, on the other hand, his intention was unknown, the penalty indeed had no force, since that according to whose model he had ordered it to be made existed nowhere, but they ought nevertheless in any case to erect a monument in accordance with the estate and dignity of the deceased.

Notes

  1. §35.1.27.prmultare — Although the passive infinitive 'multari' (that the heirs be fined) would be expected here, the manuscripts read the active 'multare'. It functions either as an infinitive depending on 'scribserat' representing the testator's instruction, or as a historical infinitive.
  2. §35.1.27.prnoluisse — The manuscripts read 'noluisse' (not to have wished), but in context it is highly likely a clerical error for 'uoluisse' (to have wished). Although translated here as 'had not wished' in accordance with the transmitted text, the practical sense of the passage suggests that the testator was suspected of actually wishing to use the existing monument of Dama as his model despite the mistake in the name.
  3. §35.1.27.prrespondit — The subject is not explicitly stated but refers to the jurist giving the response (Alfenus or his teacher Servius). The following reply is framed entirely in indirect speech with accusative and infinitive constructions (fieri debere, habere, debere).
  4. §35.1.27.prsubstantiam — Here it does not mean philosophical 'substance' but is used in the legal sense of 'estate, property, or means'. Paired with 'dignitatem' (dignity, social status), it indicates the standard that the monument should be built in proportion to the wealth left by the deceased.

Cite this passage

Justinian I, The Digest of Justinian §35.1.27.pr. Humanitext Reader, https://reader.humanitext.ai/en/text/urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:35.1.27.pr

Please note the AI-draft status of the translation and the date accessed.

Translation, notes and summary are AI-generated drafts, revised through reader feedback.