Humanitext Reader

Justinian I · The Digest of Justinian §34.3.8.pr-34.3.8.7

Release of Third-Party Debts and Scope of Release

Passage 5208 of 9271 · Latin

Summary

Pomponius discusses the validity of releasing debts of heirs or third parties, the exclusion of interest demands during forbidden periods, personal versus in rem releases, accounting requirements, and the exclusion of liability for intentional misconduct (dolus) from general releases for administrators, along with releases for depositaries and borrowers.

[POMPONIUS libro sexto ad Sabinum. ] §34.3.8.prNon solum nostrum debitorem, sed et heredis et cuiuslibet alterius ut liberetur, legare possumus.
We can bequeath so that not only our own debtor, but also that of our heir or of anyone else, may be released.
§34.3.8.1Potest heres damnari, ut ad certum tempus non petat a debitore: sed sine dubio nec liberare eum intra id tempus debebit, et, si debitor decesserit, ab herede eius intra id tempus peti non poterit.
An heir can be charged not to demand from a debtor for a certain time; but without doubt, he will not be bound to release him within that time, and, if the debtor dies, payment cannot be demanded from his heir within that time.
§34.3.8.2Illud uidendum est, an eius temporis, intra quod petere heres uetitus sit, uel usuras uel poenas petere possit.
It must be considered whether he can demand either interest or penalties for that period during which the heir is forbidden to make a demand.
et Priscus Neratius existimabat committere eum aduersus testamentum, si petisset: quod uerum est.
And Priscus Neratius was of the opinion that, if he made a demand, he acted against the testament; which is true.
§34.3.8.3Tale legatum: 'heres meus a solo Lucio Titio ne petito' ad heredem Lucii Titii non transit, si nihil uiuo Lucio Titio aduersus testamentum ab herede, eo quod ab eo exigere debitum temptauit, sit commissum: quotiens enim cohaeret personae id quod legatur, ueluti personalis seruitus, ad heredem eius non transit, si non cohaeret, transit.
Such a legacy as: 'Let my heir not demand from Lucius Titius alone' does not pass to the heir of Lucius Titius, if, during the lifetime of Lucius Titius, nothing was committed by the heir against the testament by reason of his having attempted to exact the debt from him; for whenever that which is bequeathed is attached to the person, like a personal servitude, it does not pass to his heir, but if it is not attached, it does pass.
§34.3.8.4Si uerba liberationis in rem sint collata, pro eo est, quasi heres ab eo debitore heredeque eius petere uetitus sit, ut adiectio heredis perinde nihil ualeat, atque non esset ualitura ipsius debitoris persona non comprehensa.
If the words of release are directed to the matter itself (in rem), it is just as if the heir were forbidden to demand from that debtor and his heir, so that the addition of the heir has no more effect than it would have had if the person of the debtor himself had not been included.
§34.3.8.5Is, qui reddere rationes iussus sit, non uidetur satisfacere, si reliquum reddat non editis rationibus.
He who has been ordered to render accounts is not considered to satisfy the obligation if he pays over the balance without presenting the accounts.
§34.3.8.6Si heres uetitus sit agere cum eo, qui negotia defuncti gesserit, non uidetur obligatio ei praelegata, quae dolo uel ex fraude eius qui negotia gesserit commissa sit, et testator id uidetur sensisse.
If an heir is forbidden to bring an action against one who has managed the affairs of the deceased, an obligation which was incurred through the dolus or fraud of the manager is not considered to have been pre-bequeathed to him, and the testator is deemed to have intended this.
ideo si heres negotiorum gestorum egisset, agens procurator ex testamento incerti doli mali exceptione excludi potest.
Therefore, if the heir has brought an action on managed affairs, the manager (procurator) bringing an action under a testament for an uncertain sum (ex testamento incerti) can be barred by the plea of fraud (exceptio doli mali).
§34.3.8.7Et ei liberatio recte legatur, apud quem deposuero uel cui commodauero pignoriue dedero uel ei quem ex furtiua causa mihi dare oportet.
And a release is validly bequeathed to one with whom I have deposited, or to whom I have commodated or given a pledge, or to one who is bound to give to me on account of theft.

Notes

  1. §34.3.8.prut liberetur — Third-person singular of the present passive subjunctive. It introduces a purpose or object clause depending on the verb 'legare' (to bequeath), indicating the legal end 'that he be released'. It functions as the object clause modifying the preceding accusative objects (nostrum debitorem, etc.).
  2. §34.3.8.2eius temporis — Genitive singular neuter phrase 'of that time', functioning as a genitive of relation or description modifying 'usuras uel poenas' (interest or penalties). It specifies the interest or penalties accruing 'during that time' within which the heir is forbidden to make a demand.
  3. §34.3.8.3eo quod ab eo exigere debitum temptauit — A causal clause introduced by 'eo quod' (by reason of the fact that, because). Alternatively, it can be parsed as an ablative of means/cause 'eo' (by that thing) followed by an explanatory 'quod' clause, indicating the specific action of the heir (attempting to exact the debt) that did not constitute a breach of the testament.
  4. §34.3.8.6procurator ex testamento incerti doli mali exceptione excludi potest — The 'procurator' refers to the manager of affairs mentioned earlier. 'Ex testamento incerti' designates an action based on a testament for an uncertain sum (actio ex testamento incerti), brought to enforce the release. Since obligations arising from intentional fraud (dolus) are not covered by the release, the manager bringing such an action can be barred by the defense of fraud (exceptio doli mali).

Cite this passage

Justinian I, The Digest of Justinian §34.3.8.pr-34.3.8.7. Humanitext Reader, https://reader.humanitext.ai/en/text/urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:34.3.8.pr-34.3.8.7

Please note the AI-draft status of the translation and the date accessed.

Translation, notes and summary are AI-generated drafts, revised through reader feedback.