Justinian I · The Digest of Justinian §41.3.15.pr-41.3.15.3
Usucapion by Captives and Possession of Runaway Slaves
Summary
The text discusses the validity of usucapion for a possessor captured by enemies, comparing the return of the master, the actions of a slave, and the role of inheritance upon the master's death. It also addresses the rules on possessing a runaway slave, flaws in acquiring possession twice, and the timing for evaluating good faith under a will or stipulation.
Notes
- 41.3.15.prpro emptore — 'pro emptore' (as a buyer) is a technical expression indicating the title of possession (causa possessionis). It means that the possessor began to possess based on their belief as a buyer (good faith), even if the sale itself was technically invalid or the seller lacked ownership.
- 41.3.15.prquemadmodum enim postliminio reuersus — This sentence from here to 'peruenit' is a rhetorical question explaining the case where the master returns from captivity. It argues that just as the master's rights are restored by the right of return for things possessed before captivity, his rights should be recognized for things acquired by slaves during his captivity.
- 41.3.15.prlocum non habere usucapionem — Although literally meaning 'usucapion does not have a place', in the context of Marcellus' view (applying the fiction of Lex Cornelia more broadly), it is interpreted as 'there is no room for the interruption of usucapion in the case of successors', meaning that the inheritance (hereditas) continues the personality of the deceased, allowing the usucapion to be completed without interruption.
- 41.3.15.3eius temporis existimationem nostram intuendam — 'intuendam (esse)' is an impersonal gerundive construction where 'existimationem' functions as the subject accusative. It means 'our estimation must be considered'. It shows that whether the good faith (bona fides) necessary for usucapion existed is judged at the time of the actual delivery (traditio), rather than at the time of contracting.
Cite this passage
Justinian I, The Digest of Justinian §41.3.15.pr-41.3.15.3. Humanitext Reader, https://reader.humanitext.ai/en/text/urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:41.3.15.pr-41.3.15.3
Please note the AI-draft status of the translation and the date accessed.
Translation, notes and summary are AI-generated drafts, revised through reader feedback.