Humanitext Reader

Justinian I · The Digest of Justinian §28.5.45.pr

Condition of Building a Monument and Co-heir Renunciation

Passage 4224 of 9271 · Latin

Summary

In a case where two heirs were appointed on condition of building a monument and one declined the inheritance, the remaining heir who fulfilled the condition is answered to be a valid heir, as no one should be harmed by another's failure to act.

[ALFENUS libro quinto digestorum. ] §28.5.45.prPater familias testamento duos heredes instituerat: eos monumentum facere iusserat in diebus certis: deinde ita scripserat: 'qui eorum non ita fecerit, omnes exheredes sunto': alter heres hereditatem praetermiserat, reliquus heres consulebat, cum ipse monumentum exstruxisset, numquid minus heres esset ob eam rem, quod coheres eius hereditatem non adisset.
[ALFENUS, in the fifth book of the Digests.] A paterfamilias had appointed two heirs in his will; he had ordered them to build a monument within a specified number of days, and then he had written as follows: "Whichever of them does not do so, let them all be disinherited." One of the heirs had declined the inheritance; the remaining heir, since he himself had built the monument, consulted as to whether he was any less of an heir on account of the fact that his co-heir had not entered upon the inheritance.
respondit neminem ex alterius facto hereditati neque alligari neque exheredari posse, sed uti quisque condicionem implesset, quamuis nemo adisset praeterea, tamen eum heredem esse.
He replied that no one can be either bound to an inheritance or disinherited by the act of another, but that according as each person had fulfilled the condition, even though no one else had entered upon the inheritance, he was nevertheless an heir.

Notes

  1. §28.5.45.prnumquid minus heres esset — numquid introduces an indirect question (strengthened form of num). minus is used adverbially, meaning either "not at all" (negation) or "less". The phrase asks whether he would be any less of an heir (or not an heir at all) because of his co-heir's action.
  2. §28.5.45.pruti quisque condicionem implesset — uti (an older or alternative form of ut) here functions as a relative or conditional conjunction ("as", "in proportion as", "insofar as"). implesset is a syncopated form of the pluperfect subjunctive implevisset, required by the sequence of tenses in indirect speech depending on respondit.

Cite this passage

Justinian I, The Digest of Justinian §28.5.45.pr. Humanitext Reader, https://reader.humanitext.ai/en/text/urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:28.5.45.pr

Please note the AI-draft status of the translation and the date accessed.

Translation, notes and summary are AI-generated drafts, revised through reader feedback.