Humanitext Reader

Justinian I · The Digest of Justinian §19.2.57.pr

Action for Building Collapse from Earth and Moisture

Passage 2878 of 9271 · Latin

Summary

In a case where a leased open space was piled with earth by a neighbor, causing moisture from rain to damage and collapse the lessor's building, Labeo argues that only an action on the lease is available, rather than an action for wrongful damage under the Lex Aquilia, because the damage was caused indirectly by the moisture and not directly by the piling of earth; Javolenus approves of this opinion.

[IAUOLENUS libro nono ex posterioribus Labeonis. ] §19.2.57.prQui domum habebat, aream iniunctam ei domui uicino proximo locauerat: is uicinus cum aedificaret in suo, terram in eam aream amplius quam fundamenta caementicia locatoris erant congessit, et ea terra adsiduis pluuiis inundata, ita parieti eius qui locauerat umore praestituto madefacto, aedificia corruerunt.
[JAVOLENUS, in the ninth book of his Epitomes of Labeo's Posthumous Works.] A person who owned a house had leased an open space adjacent to that house to his immediate neighbor. While this neighbor was building on his own land, he piled up earth in that open space higher than the concrete foundations of the lessor, and as this earth became saturated by continuous rains, the wall of the lessor was thus moistened by the moisture staying there, and the buildings collapsed.
Labeo ex locato tantummodo actionem esse ait, quia non ipsa congestio, sed umor ex ea congestione postea damno fuerit, damni autem iniuriae actio ob ea ipsa sit, per quae, non extrinsecus alia causa oblata, damno quis adfectus est: hoc probo.
Labeo says that there is only an action on the lease, because not the piling up of earth itself, but the moisture arising later from that piling up was the cause of the damage; and the action for wrongful damage is available for those things by which someone is affected with damage directly, without any other external cause being introduced. I approve of this.

Notes

  1. §19.2.57.prparieti... madefacto — The dative parieti in the manuscripts is generally emended to the ablative pariete to form an ablative absolute with madefacto, meaning 'the wall having been moistened.'
  2. §19.2.57.prdamno fuerit — The noun damno is a dative of purpose (part of a double dative construction), meaning 'was the cause of damage' or 'resulted in damage.'
  3. §19.2.57.prdamni... iniuriae actio — Refers to the action for wrongful damage under the Lex Aquilia (actio damni iniuriae). Since this action requires direct causation (per quae) without any intervening external cause, it is not applicable here where an external factor (rainwater) intervened after the piling of earth; hence, only the contract-based action is available.

Cite this passage

Justinian I, The Digest of Justinian §19.2.57.pr. Humanitext Reader, https://reader.humanitext.ai/en/text/urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:19.2.57.pr

Please note the AI-draft status of the translation and the date accessed.

Translation, notes and summary are AI-generated drafts, revised through reader feedback.