← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§17.2.14.pr

Agreements on Non-Division and Just Cause for Renunciation

A discussion that an agreement not to divide common property does not imply a prohibition on withdrawing from the partnership, and that even if there is an agreement not to withdraw for a certain period, a withdrawal is justified if there is a good cause, exempting the partner from liability under the action on partnership.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[ULPIANUS libro trigesimo ad Sabinum.]

[ULPIAN in his thirtieth book on Sabinus]

§17.2.14.pr

​Si conuenerit inter socios, ne intra certum tempus communis res diuidatur, non uidetur conuenisse, ne societate abeatur.1 quid tamen si hoc conuenit, ne abeatur, an ualeat? eleganter Pomponius scripsit frustra hoc conuenire: nam et si non conuenit, si tamen intempestiue renuntietur societati, esse pro socio actionem.2 sed et si conuenit, ne intra certum tempus societate abeatur, et ante tempus renuntietur, potest rationem habere renuntiatio. nec tenebitur pro socio qui ideo renuntiauit, quia condicio quaedam, qua societas erat coita, ei non praestatur: aut quid si3 ita iniuriosus et damnosus socius sit, ut non expediat eum pati?

​If it has been agreed among partners that common property shall not be divided within a certain time, it does not seem to have been agreed that there shall be no withdrawal from the partnership. But what if it is agreed that there shall be no withdrawal, would this be valid? Pomponius wrote elegantly that such an agreement is to no purpose; for even if there is no such agreement, yet if the partnership is renounced unseasonably, there is an action on the partnership. But even if it has been agreed that there shall be no withdrawal from the partnership within a certain time, and it is renounced before that time, the renunciation can have a valid reason. Nor will he be held liable under the action on the partnership who renounced for the reason that some condition, under which the partnership was contracted, is not being performed for him; or what if a partner is so injurious and damaging that it is not expedient to tolerate him?

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 17.2.14.prsocietate abeatur

    The passive third-person singular of the intransitive verb abire is used impersonally, meaning "to withdraw from the partnership." societate is an ablative of separation.

  2. 17.2.14.presse pro socio actionem

    Continuation of the indirect discourse (accusative with infinitive construction) governed by scripsit. Following the subordinate clause starting with nam, esse (infinitive) and actionem (subject accusative) form the main clause of the indirect speech.

  3. 17.2.14.prquid si

    An idiomatic interrogative expression meaning "what if..." or "what would happen if...". The omission of a verb such as fiat is assumed after quid.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · No revisions to the English translation or the originalurn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:17.2.14.pr