← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§12.6.51.pr

Irrecoverability of Payment Where Right of Retention Exists

It states that if a payment is made under a cause where there is a right of retention but no right of action (such as a natural obligation), it cannot be reclaimed.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[IDEM libro sexto ad Quintum Mucium.]

[THE SAME, in the sixth book on Quintus Mucius.]

§12.6.51.pr

​Ex quibus causis retentionem quidem habemus,1 petitionem autem non habemus, ea2 si soluerimus, repetere non possumus.

​If we have paid those things under such causes as to which we indeed have the right of retention, but do not have the right of action, we cannot reclaim them.

Syntax notes2 items
  1. 12.6.51.prretentionem quidem habemus, petitionem autem non habemus

    A contrast between the right to retain the performance (retentio) and the right to claim it through an action (petitio). This refers to legal relations (such as natural obligations) where no action is granted but voluntary payment can be lawfully retained by the creditor.

  2. 12.6.51.prEx quibus causis retentionem quidem habemus, petitionem autem non habemus, ea

    The relative clause is preposed to restrict the demonstrative pronoun ea (neuter plural accusative, 'those things') in the main/conditional clause. ea practically refers to the performance made based on the relation specified in the relative clause and serves as the direct object of the verb soluerimus.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · No revisions to the English translation or the originalurn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:12.6.51.pr