- Source
- Digesta Iustiniani Augusti. Mommsen, Theodor & Krueger, Paul, editors. Berlin: Weidmann, 1870.
- Translation
- AI-generated (gemini-3.5-flash) — machine translation; may contain errors
- Languages
- 日本語 · English · 简体中文 · 한국어
- CTS URN
- urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:12.6.38.pr-12.6.38.3
- Generated
- Humanitext Reader · reader.humanitext.ai · 2026-11-18
Discusses whether recovery is possible when a loan between brothers under the same paternal power, or between a father and his son, is paid after the father's death or the son's emancipation, focusing on the subsistence and extinction of natural obligations related to the peculium, and also covers recovery by a surety for an undue legacy.
[AFRICANUS libro nono quaestionum.]
Frater a fratre, cum in eiusdem potestate essent, pecuniam mutuatus post mortem patris ei soluit: quaesitum est, an repetere possit. respondit utique quidem pro ea parte, qua ipse patri heres exstitisset, repetiturum,1 pro ea uero, qua frater heres exstiterit, ita repetiturum, si non minus ex peculio suo ad fratrem peruenisset: naturalem enim obligationem quae fuisset hoc ipso sublatam uideri, quod peculii partem frater sit consecutus, adeo ut, si praelegatum filio eidemque debitori id fuisset, deductio huius debiti a fratre ex eo fieret. idque maxime consequens esse2 ei sententiae, quam Iulianus probaret, si extraneo quid debuisset et ab eo post mortem patris exactum esset, tantum iudicio eum familiae herciscundae reciperaturum a coheredibus fuisse, quantum ab his creditor actione de peculio consequi potuisset. igitur et si re integra familiae herciscundae agatur, ita peculium diuidi aequum esse, ut ad quantitatem eius indemnis a coherede praestetur: porro eum, quem aduersus extraneum defendi oportet, longe magis in eo, quod fratri debuisset, indemnem esse praestandum.
A brother, when they were under the power of the same father, borrowed money from his brother, and paid it to him after their father’s death; the question arose whether he could recover it. He answered that he would certainly recover it in respect of that share in which he himself had become heir to his father; but in respect of that share in which his brother had become heir, he would recover it only if no less amount from his own peculium had come to his brother. For the natural obligation which had existed is deemed to have been extinguished by the very fact that the brother obtained a portion of the peculium, so much so that if that had been pre-legacy to the same son who was also the debtor, a deduction of this debt would be made from it by the brother. And this is most consistent with the opinion which Julian approved: that if a son owed something to a stranger and it was exacted from him after the father’s death, he would recover from his co-heirs in the action for partition of inheritance only as much as the creditor could have obtained from them by the action concerning the peculium. Therefore, even if the action for partition of inheritance is brought while things are intact, it is equitable that the peculium be so divided that he is kept harmless by his co-heir up to its amount. Furthermore, he who ought to be defended against a stranger ought much more to be kept harmless in respect of what he owed to his brother.
Quaesitum est, si pater filio crediderit isque emancipatus soluat, an repetere possit. respondit, si nihil ex peculio apud patrem remanserit, non repetiturum: nam manere naturalem obligationem argumento esse, quod3 extraneo agente intra annum de peculio deduceret pater, quod sibi filius debuisset.
The question arose: if a father lent money to his son and the latter, having been emancipated, paid it, can he recover it? He answered that if nothing from the peculium remained with the father, he would not recover it; for the subsistence of the natural obligation is evidenced by the fact that if a stranger brought an action concerning the peculium within a year, the father would deduct what the son owed him.
Contra si pater quod filio debuisset eidem emancipato soluerit, non repetet: nam hic quoque manere naturalem obligationem eodem argumento probatur, quod, si extraneus intra annum de peculio agat, etiam quod pater ei debuisset computetur. eademque erunt et si extraneus heres exheredato filio soluerit id, quod ei pater debuisset.
Conversely, if a father paid what he owed to his son to the same son after his emancipation, he will not recover it; for here too, the subsistence of the natural obligation is proved by the same argument, namely, that if a stranger brings an action concerning the peculium within a year, what the father owed him is also taken into account. And the same will apply if an outside heir pays to a disinherited son what the father owed him.
Legati satis accepi et cum fideiussor mihi soluisset, apparuit indebitum fuisse legatum: posse eum repetere existimauit.
I received security for a legacy, and when the surety had paid me, it appeared that the legacy had not been due. He was of the opinion that the surety could recover it.
- 12.6.38.prrepetiturum
The omitted subject of the future active infinitive repetiturum (with esse understood) is Frater (the brother who borrowed and paid the money) from the main clause. Both occurrences of repetiturum depend on the verb respondit to form part of the indirect discourse.
- 12.6.38.pridque maxime consequens esse
This sentence consists of idque (subject) and maxime consequens esse (predicate), with ei sententiae serving as the dative complement of consequens. Within the relative clause quam Iulianus probaret modifying sententiae, a conditional sentence is embedded, where tantum ... reciperaturum ... fuisse represents the apodosis (originally pluperfect subjunctive) in indirect discourse, coupled with the protasis si ... exactum esset.
- 12.6.38.1argumento esse, quod
argumento is a predicative dative (dative of purpose/effect), with the substantive quod clause serving as the subject of esse, while the infinitive phrase manere naturalem obligationem specifies the proposition that is proved (argumento).
Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · Revisions to the English translation and the original (1, latest 2026-11-15)
- 2026-11-15 AI review — note 1
