← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§10.2.18.pr-10.2.18.7

Settlement of Expenses and Debts in Division of Inheritance

Explains through various juristic opinions how issues such as wrongful acts by a bequeathed slave, the building of a monument, expenses made in good faith, joint debts, and payments made to protect possession are handled in the action for dividing a family inheritance.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[ULPIANUS libro nono decimo ad edictum.]

[ULPIAN, On the Edict, book 19]

§10.2.18.pr

​His consequenter Iulianus ait: si ex pluribus heredibus uni seruus sit generaliter per optionem legatus et heredes Stichum tabulas hereditarias interleuisse1 dicant uel corrupisse et propter hoc renuntiauerint, ne optaretur seruus, deinde optatus uindicetur, poterunt, si ab eis uindicetur, doli mali exceptione uti et de seruo quaestionem habere.2

​Consistent with this, Julian says: if a slave was bequeathed generally by option to one of several heirs, and the heirs allege that the slave Stichus tampered with or corrupted the tablets of the inheritance and for this reason registered their protest lest the slave be chosen, and then, having been chosen, the slave is claimed, they will be able, if he is claimed from them, to use the exception of fraud and to have an inquiry concerning the slave.

§10.2.18.1

​Sed an in familiae erciscundae iudicium de morte testatoris uel de morte uxoris liberorumque suorum habebunt quaestionem heredes, quaeritur: et rectissime Pomponius ait haec ad diuisionem rerum hereditariarum non pertinere.

​But it is asked whether the heirs will have an inquiry concerning the death of the testator or the death of his wife and children in the trial for dividing a family inheritance: and Pomponius most correctly says that these matters do not pertain to the division of the inheritance assets.

§10.2.18.2

​Idem quaerit, si quis testamento cauerit, ut seruus exportandus ueneat, officio familiae erciscundae iudicis contineri, ut uoluntas defuncti non intercidat. sed et cum monumentum iussit testator fieri, familiae erciscundae agent, ut fiat. idem tamen temptat, quia heredum interest, quos ius monumenti sequitur, praescriptis uerbis3 posse eos experiri, ut monumentum fiat.

​The same asks: if anyone provided in a will that a slave should be sold on condition of being exported, is it contained in the duty of the judge of family inheritance division that the will of the deceased should not fail? But also, when the testator has ordered a monument to be made, they will sue under the action for dividing family inheritance so that it may be made. The same writer, however, suggests that, because it is of interest to the heirs whom the right of the monument follows, they can proceed by an action in prescribed words to have the monument made.

§10.2.18.3

​Sumptuum, quos unus ex heredibus bona fide fecerit, usuras quoque consequi potest a coherede ex die morae secundum rescriptum imperatorum Seueri et Antonini.

​Of the expenses which one of the heirs has incurred in good faith, he can also obtain interest from his co-heir from the day of default, according to the rescript of the Emperors Severus and Antoninus.

§10.2.18.4

​Celsus etiam illud eleganter adicit coheredem et si non soluit habere4 familiae erciscundae iudicium, ut cogatur coheres soluere, cum alias non sit liberaturus rem creditor, nisi in solidum ei satisfiat.

​Celsus also elegantly adds this: that a co-heir, even if he has not paid, has the action for dividing family inheritance so that the co-heir may be compelled to pay, since otherwise the creditor is not going to release the thing unless satisfaction is made to him in full.

§10.2.18.5

​Si filius familias patri heres pro parte extitisset et a creditoribus peculiaribus conueniretur, cum paratus sit soluere id omne quod debetur, per doli exceptionem consequetur a creditoribus mandari sibi actiones: sed etiam familiae erciscundae iudicium cum coheredibus haberet.

​If a son-in-power had stood as heir to his father for a share and was sued by the creditors of his peculium, since he is ready to pay all that is owed, he will obtain through the exception of fraud that the actions be assigned to him by the creditors; but he would also have the action for dividing family inheritance against the co-heirs.

§10.2.18.6

​Cum unus ex heredibus legatum exsoluit ei, qui missus fuerat in possessionem legatorum seruandorum causa, putat Papinianus, et uerum est, familiae erciscundae iudicium ei competere aduersus coheredes, quia non alias discederet legatarius a possessione, quam uice pignoris erat consecutus, quam si5 totum ei legatum fuisset exsolutum.

​When one of the heirs has paid a legacy to him who had been put in possession for the sake of preserving legacies, Papinian thinks, and it is true, that the action for dividing family inheritance is available to him against the co-heirs, because the legatee would not otherwise depart from the possession, which he had obtained in place of a pledge, unless the legacy had been paid to him in full.

§10.2.18.7

​Sed et si quis Titio debitum soluerit, ne pignus ueniret, Neratius scribit familiae erciscundae iudicio eum posse experiri.

​But also, if anyone has paid a debt to Titius lest a pledge be sold, Neratius writes that he can sue under the action for dividing family inheritance.

Syntax notes5 items
  1. 10.2.18.printerleuisse

    Meaning "to smear between" or "to erase/interpolate". Here it refers to illegally altering, erasing, or inserting text in the testamentary tablets.

  2. 10.2.18.prquaestionem habere

    In ancient Roman law, this refers to "interrogation under torture" of slaves. Unlike ordinary witnesses, the testimony of slaves was as a rule taken under torture.

  3. 10.2.18.2praescriptis uerbis

    Refers to the "action in prescribed words" (actio praescriptis uerbis). A procedural remedy used, for instance, in innominate contracts that do not fit standard categories, where the facts are set forth at the beginning of the formula to claim performance.

  4. 10.2.18.4coheredem ... habere

    Accusative with Infinitive (AcI) construction introduced by the verb "adicit". "coheredem" is the subject accusative, and the adverbial "et" modifies "si non soluit" ("even if he has not paid").

  5. 10.2.18.6non alias ... quam si

    A comparative construction expressing a strong restrictive condition: "not otherwise ... than if". Here it means the legatee would "not depart from the possession unless the legacy had been paid in full."

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · No revisions to the English translation or the originalurn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:10.2.18.pr-10.2.18.7