← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§8.2.23.pr-8.2.23.1

Interpretation of Light Servitudes and Future Buildings

This chunk discusses the interpretive differences regarding future lights based on the wording of servitudes ("maintaining existing lights" vs. "no obstruction of lights"), and states that servitudes can be established on or for future buildings.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[POMPONIUS libro trigensimo tertio ad Sabinum.]

[POMPONIUS, in the thirty-third book on Sabinus.]

§8.2.23.pr

​Si seruitus imposita fuerit 'lumina quae nunc sunt, ut ita sint1', de futuris luminibus nihil caueri uidetur: quod si ita sit cautum 'ne luminibus officiatur2', ambigua est scriptura, utrum ne his luminibus officiatur quae nunc sint, an etiam his quae postea quoque fuerint: et humanius est uerbo generali omne lumen significari,3 siue quod in praesenti siue quod post tempus conuentionis contigerit.

​If a servitude has been imposed in the terms “the lights which now exist, that they shall remain as they are”, it seems that nothing is provided for future lights; but if it has been so provided “that the lights be not obstructed”, the wording is ambiguous, whether it means that those lights which now exist be not obstructed, or also those which shall also exist hereafter; and it is more equitable that by the general term every light is meant, whether that which exists at present, or that which has arisen after the time of the agreement.

§8.2.23.1

​Futuro quoque aedificio,4 quod nondum est, uel imponi uel adquiri seruitus potest.

​Also on or for a future building, which does not yet exist, a servitude can be either imposed or acquired.

Syntax notes4 items
  1. 8.2.23.prlumina quae nunc sunt, ut ita sint

    A direct quotation of the agreed wording in establishing the servitude. The ut clause (ut ita sint) functions as a noun clause specifying the content of the agreement ("that they shall remain as they are").

  2. 8.2.23.prne luminibus officiatur

    The intransitive verb officere (which takes the dative to mean "to obstruct, interfere with") is used in the impersonal passive. The dative luminibus is retained as a dative, meaning "lest the lights be obstructed".

  3. 8.2.23.pruerbo generali omne lumen significari

    An accusative with infinitive (AcI) construction, where omne lumen is the subject accusative of the infinitive significari. It functions as the subject of the impersonal phrase humanius est ("it is more equitable/humane").

  4. 8.2.23.1Futuro quoque aedificio

    Dative modifying imponi (to be imposed) and adquiri (to be acquired). It indicates that a servitude can be established even for or upon a future building that does not yet exist.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12)urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:8.2.23.pr-8.2.23.1