← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§7.1.19.pr-7.1.19.1

Conditional Usufruct of Buildings and Fallen Trees

This chunk explains Proculus' view on bequeathing the usufruct of a building under the condition of not raising its height, and the legal remedies available to the usufructuary when the owner fails to remove wind-blown trees.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[POMPONIUS libro quinto ad Sabinum.]

[POMPONIUS in the fifth book on Sabinus.]

§7.1.19.pr

​Proculus putat insulam posse ita legari, ut ei seruitus imponatur, quae alteri insulae hereditariae debeatur, hoc modo: 'Si ille heredi meo promiserit per se non fore, quo altius ea aedificia tollantur,1 tum ei eorum aedificiorum usum fructum do lego' uel sic: 'Aedium illarum, quoad altius, quam uti nunc sunt, aedificatae non erunt, illi usum fructum do lego.'

​Proculus thinks that a block of flats (insula) can be so bequeathed that a servitude is imposed on it which is owed to another block of flats belonging to the inheritance, in this manner: ‘If he promises my heir that he will not do anything to prevent those buildings from being raised higher, then I give and bequeath the usufruct of those buildings to him,’ or thus: ‘I give and bequeath to him the usufruct of those buildings, as long as they are not built higher than they are now.’

§7.1.19.1

​Si arbores uento deiectas dominus non tollat, per quod incommodior is sit usus fructus uel iter, suis actionibus usufructuario cum eo experiundum.2

​If the owner does not remove trees blown down by the wind, whereby the usufruct or the right of way becomes less convenient, the usufructuary must take legal action against him with his own remedies.

Syntax notes2 items
  1. 7.1.19.prper se non fore, quo altius ea aedificia tollantur

    An infinitive clause acting as the object of promiserit (if he promises). per se non fore (that it will not happen through him) is followed by a clause introduced by the conjunction quo (functioning similarly to quo minus), meaning 'that he will not do anything to prevent those buildings from being raised higher.'

  2. 7.1.19.1usufructuario cum eo experiundum

    In this impersonal gerundive construction experiundum [esse] (one must proceed/take action), the agent performing the action is expressed by the dative usufructuario (by the usufructuary). cum eo (with him) refers to the dominus (owner) mentioned in the conditional clause.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12)urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:7.1.19.pr-7.1.19.1