← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§6.1.59.pr

Recovery of Fixtures Detached from Another's Building

Regarding windows and doors fitted into another's building, they belong to the building while joined to it, but once removed, they revert to their former status, allowing the installer to claim them.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[IULIANUS libro sexto ex Minicio.]

[JULIANUS in the sixth book from Minicius.]

§6.1.59.pr

​Habitator in aliena aedificia fenestras et ostia imposuit, eadem post annum dominus aedificiorum dempsit: quaero, is qui imposuerat possetne ea uindicare. respondit posse: nam quae alienis aedificiis conexa essent,1 ea quamdiu iuncta manerent, eorundem aedificiorum2 esse, simul atque inde dempta essent, continuo in pristinam causam3 reuerti.

​An occupant fitted windows and doors into another person’s building, and after a year the owner of the building removed them. I ask whether the person who had fitted them could claim them. He replied that he could; for what has been connected to another’s building belongs to that same building as long as it remains joined to it, but as soon as it is removed from there, it immediately reverts to its former status.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 6.1.59.prconexa essent

    Since this is a subordinate clause (relative clause) within indirect speech (accusative and infinitive) depending on respondit, the pluperfect subjunctive (conexa essent) is used. Similarly, the subsequent verbs manerent (imperfect subjunctive) and dempta essent (pluperfect subjunctive) are in the subjunctive due to being inside indirect speech.

  2. 6.1.59.preorundem aedificiorum

    This is a genitive of possession, used with the infinitive esse to mean "belongs to the same building." It expresses the legal principle of accession (where the accessory thing is absorbed by the principal).

  3. 6.1.59.prpristinam causam

    In this context, causa does not mean "cause" or "lawsuit" but rather the "legal status" or "condition" of the property. Therefore, it refers to reverting to its original state of independent ownership prior to being attached to the building.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12)urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:6.1.59.pr