← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§17.2.23.pr-17.2.23.1

Admitted Partner's Fault and Denial of Set-Off with Profit

Addresses the scope of liability for a partner who single-handedly admitted a new member, and rejects the view that profits from the new member's activities can offset the damages caused by their negligence.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[ULPIANUS libro trigesimo ad Sabinum.]

[ULPIAN in his thirtieth book on Sabinus]

§17.2.23.pr

​De illo Pomponius dubitat, utrum actionem eum mandare sociis sufficit,1 ut, si facere ille non possit, nihil ultra sociis praestet, an uero indemnes eos praestare debeat. et puto omnimodo eum teneri eius nomine, quem ipse solus admisit, quia difficile est negare culpa ipsius admissum.2

​On this point, Pomponius doubts whether it is sufficient for him to delegate the action to the partners so that, if that person is unable to pay, he makes good nothing further to the partners, or whether indeed he ought to keep them harmless. And I think that he is bound in every way on account of the person whom he himself alone admitted, because it is difficult to deny that the person was admitted through his own fault.

§17.2.23.1

​Idem quaerit, an commodum, quod propter admissum socium3 accessit, compensari cum damno, quod culpa praebuit, debeat, et ait compensandum. quod non est uerum, nam et Marcellus libro sexto digestorum scribit, si seruus unius ex sociis societati a domino praepositus neglegenter uersatus sit, dominum societati qui praeposuerit praestaturum nec compensandum commodum, quod per seruum societati accessit, cum damno: et ita diuum Marcum pronuntiasse, nec posse dici socio: 'abstine commodo,4 quod per seruum accessit, si damnum petis.'

​The same person asks whether the benefit which accrued on account of the admitted partner ought to be set off against the damage which his fault caused, and says that it should be set off. This is not correct, for Marcellus also writes in the sixth book of his Digests that, if a slave of one of the partners, having been placed in charge of the partnership by his master, has behaved negligently, the master who placed him in charge must make it good to the partnership, and the benefit which accrued to the partnership through the slave must not be set off against the damage; and that the deified Marcus so decided, and that it cannot be said to the partner: “Abstain from the benefit which accrued through the slave, if you seek damages.”

Syntax notes4 items
  1. 17.2.23.practionem eum mandare sociis sufficit

    The accusative-with-infinitive clause actionem eum mandare sociis serves as the subject of the impersonal verb sufficit. eum (referring to the admitting partner) is the subject accusative of the infinitive mandare.

  2. 17.2.23.prculpa ipsius admissum

    An accusative-with-infinitive clause serving as the object of negare, where esse is omitted from admissum [esse]. The subject accusative (the person admitted) is also omitted as it is clear from the context: "that [the person] was admitted through his own fault."

  3. 17.2.23.1propter admissum socium

    A construction of the 'ab urbe condita' type, where the noun combined with a perfect participle expresses an event: not literally 'on account of the admitted partner', but 'on account of the partner having been admitted' or 'due to the admission of the partner'.

  4. 17.2.23.1abstine commodo

    The second-person singular active imperative abstine of the verb abstinere, which governs the ablative case commodo (ablative of separation), meaning 'abstain from the benefit' or 'give up the advantage'.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · No revisions to the English translation or the originalurn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:17.2.23.pr-17.2.23.1