- Source
- Digesta Iustiniani Augusti. Mommsen, Theodor & Krueger, Paul, editors. Berlin: Weidmann, 1870.
- Translation
- AI-generated (gemini-3.5-flash) — machine translation; may contain errors
- Languages
- 日本語 · English · 简体中文 · 한국어
- CTS URN
- urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:17.1.12.pr-17.1.12.9
- Generated
- Humanitext Reader · reader.humanitext.ai · 2026-11-22
Discusses various cases concerning the recovery of expenses and interest in actions on mandate, involving sons-in-power, slaves, and freedmen, while explaining the opinions of Marcellus, Neratius, and Papinian on the equitable assessment of interest by judges.
[ULPIANUS libro trigensimo primo ad edictum.]
[ULPIANUS libro trigensimo primo ad edictum.]
Si uero non remunerandi causa, sed principaliter donando1 fideiussori remisit actionem, mandati eum non acturum. cellus2 autem fatetur, si quis donaturus3 fideiussori pro eo soluerit creditori, habere fideiussorem mandati actionem.
But if he released the action to the guarantor not for the sake of rewarding him, but principally by way of donation, [Marcellus says] that he will not bring an action on mandate. However, [he] admits that if someone, intending to make a donation to the guarantor, pays the creditor on his behalf, the guarantor has an action on mandate.
Plane, inquit, si filius familias uel seruus fuit fideiussor et pro his soluero donaturus eis, mandati patrem uel dominum non acturos, hoc ideo, quia4 non patri donatum uoluit.
Clearly, he says, if a son-in-power or a slave was the guarantor, and I pay on their behalf intending to make a donation to them, the father or the master will not bring an action on mandate; this is because he did not wish a donation to be made to the father.
Plane si seruus fideiussor soluerit, dominum mandati acturum idem Marcellus ibidem ait.
Clearly, if a slave who is a guarantor has paid, the same Marcellus says in the same place that the master will bring an action on mandate.
Si filius familias non iussu patris fideiusserit, cessat mandati actio, si nihil sit in peculio: quod si iussu, uel ex peculio solutum est, multo magis habet pater mandati.
If a son-in-power becomes a guarantor without the order of his father, the action on mandate does not lie if there is nothing in his peculium; but if it was by order, or if payment was made from the peculium, the father has all the more an action on mandate.
Si filio familias mandaui, ut pro me solueret, patrem, siue ipse soluerit siue filius ex peculio, mandati acturum Neratius ait, quod habet rationem: nihil enim mea interest, quis soluat.
If I commission a son-in-power to pay on my behalf, Neratius says that the father will bring an action on mandate, whether the father himself pays or the son pays from the peculium; this is reasonable, for it makes no difference to me who pays.
Si filio familias mandauero, ut pro me solueret, et emancipatus soluat, uerum est in factum actionem filio dandam, patrem autem post emancipationem soluentem negotiorum gestorum actionem habere.
If I commission a son-in-power to pay on my behalf, and he pays after being emancipated, it is true that an action on the case (in factum) should be given to the son, whereas a father who pays after the emancipation has an action for unauthorized agency (negotiorum gestorum).
Contrario iudicio experiuntur qui mandatum susceperunt, ut puta qui rerum uel rei unius procurationem susceperunt.
Those who have undertaken a mandate, for instance, those who have undertaken the administration of all affairs or of a single matter, sue by means of the contrary action.
Inde Papinianus quaerit, si patronus praedium quod emerat, pro quo pretii bessem exsoluerat, iusserit liberto suo tradi, ut ille residuum pretii redderet, deinde reddito pretio uendenti fundum patrono libertus consenserit, trientis pretium an libertus possit repetere. et ait, si mandatum suscepit initio libertus, non donatum accepit, contrario iudicio posse eum pretium repetere, quod deductis mercedibus, quas medio tempore percepit, superest: quod si donationem patronus in libertum contulit, uideri et postea libertum patrono donasse.
Hence Papinian asks: if a patron ordered a tract of land which he had bought, and for which he had paid two-thirds of the price, to be delivered to his freedman so that the latter might pay the remainder of the price, and then, after the price had been paid, the freedman agreed to the patron’s selling the land, can the freedman recover the one-third of the price? And he says that if the freedman undertook a mandate at the beginning, and did not receive a donation, he can recover by the contrary action the price which remains after deducting the rents he received in the meantime; but if the patron conferred a donation on the freedman, it appears that the freedman subsequently made a donation to the patron.
Si mihi mandaueris, ut rem tibi aliquam emam, egoque emero meo pretio, habebo mandati actionem de pretio reciperando: sed et si tuo pretio, impendero tamen aliquid bona fide ad emptionem rei, erit contraria mandati actio: aut si rem emptam nolis recipere: simili modo et si quid aliud mandaueris et in id sumptum fecero. nec tantum id quod impendi, uerum usuras quoque consequar. usuras autem non tantum ex mora esse admittendas, uerum iudicem aestimare debere, si exegit a debitore suo quis et soluit, cum uberrimas usuras consequeretur, aequissimum enim erit rationem eius rei haberi: aut si ipse mutuatus grauibus usuris soluit. sed et si reum usuris non releuauit, ipsi autem et usurae absunt, uel si minoribus releuauit, ipse autem maioribus faenus accepit, ut fidem suam liberaret, non dubito debere eum mandati iudicio et usuras consequi. et (ut est constitutum) totum hoc ex aequo et bono5 iudex arbitrabitur.
If you commission me to buy some thing for you, and I buy it with my own money, I shall have an action on mandate to recover the price; but even if it was with your money, if I nevertheless spend something in good faith for the purchase of the thing, there will be a contrary action on mandate; or if you are unwilling to receive the thing bought; and likewise if you commission anything else and I incur expense on it. And I shall obtain not only what I spent, but also interest. However, interest is not to be allowed only on account of default, but the judge ought to estimate it, if someone collected money from his own debtor and paid it, when he was obtaining very high interest, for it will be most equitable that account be taken of this matter; or if he himself borrowed and paid at heavy interest. But even if he did not relieve the principal debtor of interest, yet he himself is deprived of interest, or if he relieved him of lesser interest, while he himself took a loan at higher interest in order to discharge his credit, I have no doubt that he ought to obtain interest also in the action on mandate. And (as has been established) the judge will decide all this according to equity and good conscience.
- 17.1.12.prnon remunerandi causa, sed principaliter donando
The former phrase remunerandi causa is a purposive expression using the genitive of the gerund with causa, while the latter donando is the ablative of the gerund expressing means or cause. Two contrasting concepts are juxtaposed with asymmetrical grammatical structures.
- 17.1.12.prcellus
A corrupt reading in the manuscript, which should be restored to "Marcellus". It serves as the subject for "autem fatetur" at the beginning of 12.1.
- 17.1.12.1donaturus
A future active participle used adverbially to express the intention or purpose of the subject of the clause ("with the intention of making a donation").
- 17.1.12.2hoc ideo, quia
An idiomatic ellipsis of the copula est (hoc ideo [est], quia...), meaning "this is because...". Additionally, esse is omitted after donatum in the accusative with infinitive construction (donatum [esse] uoluit).
- 17.1.12.9ex aequo et bono
A classical legal phrase meaning "according to equity and good conscience". It indicates that since the action on mandate is a bona fide action (iudicium bonae fidei), the judge has the authority to decide based on substantive equity rather than strict legal formalism.
Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · Revisions to the English translation and the original (2, latest 2026-11-15)
- 2026-11-15 AI review — translation 1
- 2026-09-21 AI review — note 1
