← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§13.6.17.pr-13.6.17.5

Invalidity of Fraud Waiver and Untimely Revocation

Paulus discusses the invalidity of agreements to waive liability for fraud in loans for use, the conditions for bringing a counter-action, and the prohibition of untimely revocation or demand for return, while providing specific rulings on jointly lent items and retrieval after loss.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[PAULUS libro uicensimo nono ad edictum.]

[PAULUS in the twenty-ninth book on the Edict.]

§13.6.17.pr

​In commodato haec pactio, ne dolus praestetur,1 rata non est.

​In a loan for use, an agreement that there shall be no liability for fraud is not valid.

§13.6.17.1

​Contraria commodati actio etiam sine principali moueri potest, sicut et ceterae quae dicuntur contrariae.

​The counter-action on loan can be brought even without the principal action, just as the other actions which are called counter-actions.

§13.6.17.2

​Si ex facto heredis agatur commodati, in solidum condemnatur, licet ex parte heres est.2

​If an action on loan is brought on account of an act of an heir, he is condemned for the whole amount, even though he is an heir only for a part.

§13.6.17.3

​Sicut autem uoluntatis et officii magis quam necessitatis est3 commodare, ita modum commodati finemque praescribere eius est qui beneficium tribuit. cum autem id fecit, id est postquam commodauit, tunc finem praescribere et retro agere atque intempestiue usum commodatae rei auferre non officium tantum impedit, sed et suscepta obligatio inter dandum accipiendumque. geritur enim negotium inuicem et ideo inuicem propositae sunt actiones, ut appareat, quod principio beneficii ac nudae uoluntatis fuerat, conuerti in mutuas praestationes actionesque ciuiles. ut accidit in eo, qui absentis negotia gerere inchoauit: neque enim impune peritura deseret: suscepisset enim fortassis alius, si is non coepisset: uoluntatis est enim suscipere mandatum, necessitatis consummare. igitur si pugillares mihi commodasti, ut debitor mihi caueret, non recte facies importune repetendo: nam si negasses, uel emissem uel testes adhibuissem. idemque est, si ad fulciendam insulam tigna commodasti, deinde protraxisti aut etiam sciens uitiosa commodaueris: adiuuari quippe nos, non decipi beneficio oportet. ex quibus causis etiam contrarium iudicium utile esse dicendum est.

​Moreover, just as lending is a matter of free will and moral duty rather than of necessity, so prescribing the measure and limit of the loan belongs to him who confers the benefit. But when he has done this, that is, after he has lent [the thing], then to prescribe a limit, to revoke [the transaction], and untimely to deprive [the borrower] of the use of the lent thing is not only prevented by moral duty, but also by the obligation undertaken between giving and receiving. For the business is transacted mutually, and therefore actions are mutually provided, so that it appears that what in the beginning had been a matter of benefit and mere free will is converted into mutual performances and civil actions; as happens in the case of one who has begun to manage the affairs of an absent person; for he shall not with impunity abandon things that are about to perish; for perhaps someone else would have undertaken them, if he had not begun. For undertaking a mandate is a matter of free will, but completing it is a matter of necessity. Therefore, if you lent me writing-tablets so that a debtor might give me security, you will not do rightly by demanding them back importunately; for if you had refused, I would have either bought them or employed witnesses. And it is the same if you lent beams to prop up a tenement building, and then withdrew them, or even if you knowingly lent defective ones; for we ought to be helped, not deceived, by a benefit. For these reasons, it must be said that a counter-action is also available.

§13.6.17.4

​Duabus rebus commodatis recte de altera commodati agi posse Uiuianus scripsit: quod ita uideri uerum, si separatae sint, Pomponius scripsit: nam eum, qui carrucam puta uel lecticam commodauit, non recte acturum de singulis partibus.

​Vivianus wrote that if two things have been lent, an action on loan can rightly be brought for one of them; Pomponius wrote that this seems to be true only if they are separate; for a person who has lent, say, a carriage or a litter, will not rightly bring an action for the individual parts.

§13.6.17.5

​Rem commodatam perdidi et pro ea pretium dedi, deinde res in potestate tua uenit: Labeo ait contrario iudicio aut rem mihi praestare te debere aut quod a me accepisti reddere.

​I lost the lent thing and gave you its price, then the thing came into your possession; Labeo says that by a counter-action you ought either to deliver the thing to me or to return what you received from me.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 13.6.17.prne dolus praestetur

    This ne clause functions as an appositive (noun) clause explaining the content of the preceding noun phrase haec pactio ("this agreement"), indicating the terms of the agreement ("that there shall be no liability for fraud").

  2. 13.6.17.2licet ex parte heres est

    The concessive conjunction licet ("even though") usually takes the subjunctive in classical prose, but here it is used with the indicative present est. This reflects colloquial influence or the simplification of mood usage in post-classical legal Latin.

  3. 13.6.17.3uoluntatis et officii magis quam necessitatis est

    This is a genitive of characteristic or property (possessive genitive) with the infinitive commodare as the subject, meaning "lending belongs to / is a matter of free will...".

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · Revisions to the English translation and the original (2, latest 2026-09-22)
  • 2026-09-22 AI review — source 2
urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:13.6.17.pr-13.6.17.5