- Source
- Digesta Iustiniani Augusti. Mommsen, Theodor & Krueger, Paul, editors. Berlin: Weidmann, 1870.
- Translation
- AI-generated (gemini-3.5-flash) — machine translation; may contain errors
- Languages
- 日本語 · English · 简体中文 · 한국어
- CTS URN
- urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:12.6.60.pr-12.6.60.1
- Generated
- Humanitext Reader · reader.humanitext.ai · 2026-11-18
Discusses the opinions of Julian and Paulus on whether a true debtor can recover a payment made during a pending trial or under a pending novation where the debtor's ultimate liability is certain.
[PAULUS libro tertio quaestionum.]
[PAULUS, in the third book of Questions.]
Iulianus uerum debitorem post litem contestatam manente adhuc iudicio1 negabat soluentem repetere posse, quia nec absolutus nec condemnatus repetere posset: licet enim absolutus sit, natura tamen debitor permanet: similemque esse ei dicit, qui ita promisit, siue nauis ex Asia uenerit siue non uenerit, quia ex una causa alterius solutionis origo proficiscitur.
Julian denied that a true debtor, after joinder of issue (litis contestatio) and while the trial is still pending, could recover what he has paid, because neither one who has been acquitted nor one who has been condemned can recover; for even though he is acquitted, he nevertheless remains a debtor in natural law. And he says that such a debtor is similar to one who has promised thus: “whether a ship comes from Asia or does not come,” because from a single cause arises the origin of one or the other payment.
Ubi autem quis quod pure debet sub condicione nouandi animo promisit, plerique putant pendente nouatione2 solutum repetere posse, quia ex qua obligatione soluat, adhuc incertum sit: idemque esse etiam, si diuersas personas ponas eandem pecuniam pure et sub condicione nouandi animo promisisse. sed hoc dissimile est: in stipulatione enim pura et condicionali eundem debiturum3 certum est.
But where anyone has promised under a condition, with the intention of creating a novation (animus novandi), what he owes unconditionally, most jurists think that he can recover what he paid while the novation is pending, because it is still uncertain under which obligation he is paying. The same is held even if you assume that different persons have promised the same money, one unconditionally and the other under a condition with the intention of creating a novation. But this is different; for in an unconditional and a conditional stipulation, it is certain that the same person will be the debtor.
- 12.6.60.prmanente adhuc iudicio
Ablative absolute construction consisting of the noun iudicio and the present participle manente, expressing the temporal circumstance "while the trial is still pending."
- 12.6.60.1pendente nouatione
Ablative absolute construction consisting of the noun nouatione and the present participle pendente, meaning "while the novation is pending (undecided)."
- 12.6.60.1debiturum
Accusative masculine singular of the future participle debiturus. It functions with the subject accusative eundem in an accusative and infinitive construction subject to certum est, with the infinitive esse omitted.
