← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§12.6.23.pr-12.6.23.4

Recovery of Payments Made Under a Failed or Invalid Compromise

Discusses whether a claim for recovery (condictio) is available when a compromise (transactio) is non-existent, invalid, rescinded, or not stood by, and the relationship between such recovery, pleas, and judgments.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[ULPIANUS libro quadragensimo tertio ad Sabinum.]

[ULPIANUS, On Sabinus, Book 43.]

§12.6.23.pr

​Eleganter Pomponius quaerit, si quis suspicetur transactionem factam uel ab eo cui heres est1 uel ab eo cui procurator est et quasi ex transactione dederit, quae facta non est, an locus sit repetitioni. et ait repeti posse: ex falsa enim causa datum est. idem puto dicendum et si transactio secuta non fuerit, propter quam datum est: sed et si resoluta sit transactio, idem erit dicendum.

​Pomponius elegantly asks, if anyone should suspect that a compromise has been made either by the person to whom he is heir or by the person for whom he is procurator, and should give as if on the basis of a compromise, which was not made, whether there is room for recovery. And he says that it can be recovered: for it was given on a false ground. I think the same must be said even if the compromise, for the sake of which the payment was made, has not followed: but also if the compromise has been rescinded, the same will have to be said.

§12.6.23.1

​Si post rem iudicatam quis transegerit et soluerit, repetere poterit idcirco, quia placuit transactionem nullius esse momenti: hoc enim imperator Antoninus cum diuo patre suo rescripsit. retineri tamen atque compensari in causam iudicati, quod ob talem transactionem solutum est,2 potest. quid ergo si appellatum sit uel hoc ipsum incertum sit, an iudicatum sit uel an sententia ualeat? magis est, ut transactio uires habeat: tunc enim rescriptis locum esse credendum est, cum de sententia indubitata, quae nullo remedio adtemptari potest, transigitur.

​If anyone should compromise and pay after judgment, he will be able to recover for the reason that it was decided that a compromise is of no effect: for the Emperor Antoninus with his deified father so replied. It is possible, however, for what was paid on account of such a compromise to be retained and set off against the judgment debt. What then if an appeal has been made, or if this very point is uncertain, whether there has been a judgment or whether the sentence is valid? It is more reasonable that the compromise should have force: for then it must be believed that there is room for the imperial rescripts, when the compromise is made regarding an indubitable sentence, which cannot be attacked by any remedy.

§12.6.23.2

​Item si ob transactionem alimentorum testamento relictorum datum sit, apparet posse repeti quod datum est, quia transactio senatus consulto infirmatur.

​Likewise, if payment has been made on account of a compromise of maintenance left by a will, it is clear that what was given can be recovered, because the compromise is invalidated by a senatusconsultum.

§12.6.23.3

​Si quis post transactionem nihilo minus condemnatus fuerit, dolo quidem id fit, sed tamen sententia ualet. potuit autem quis, si quidem ante litem contestatam transegerit, uolenti litem contestari opponere doli exceptionem: sed si post litem contestatam transactum est, nihilo minus poterit exceptione doli uti post secuti:3 dolo enim facit, qui contra transactionem expertus4 amplius petit. ideo condemnatus repetere potest, quod ex causa transactionis dedit. sane quidem ob causam dedit neque repeti solet quod ob causam datum est causa secuta: sed hic non uidetur causa secuta, cum transactioni non stetur. cum igitur repetitio oritur, transactionis exceptio locum non habet: neque enim utrumque debet locum habere et repetitio et exceptio.

​If anyone, after a compromise, should nevertheless be condemned, this is indeed done by fraud, but the sentence is nevertheless valid. But anyone, if indeed he compromised before joinder of issue, could have opposed the plea of fraud to the person wishing to join issue: but if the compromise was made after joinder of issue, he will nevertheless be able to use the plea of fraud that followed afterwards: for he acts with fraud, who, having sued contrary to the compromise, seeks more. Therefore, the person condemned can recover what he gave on account of the compromise. To be sure, he gave for a cause, and what is given for a cause is not accustomed to be recovered when the cause has followed: but here the cause does not seem to have followed, since the compromise is not stood by. When, therefore, recovery arises, the plea of compromise has no place: for both recovery and plea ought not to have place.

§12.6.23.4

​Si qua lex ab initio dupli uel quadrupli statuit actionem, dicendum est solutum ex falsa eius causa repeti posse.

​If any law from the beginning has established an action for double or quadruple, it must be said that what was paid on its false ground can be recovered.

Syntax notes4 items
  1. 12.6.23.prcui heres est ... cui procurator est

    The relative pronoun cui in both instances is a dative governed by heres and procurator respectively, referring back to the antecedent eo ('the person to whom he is heir / for whom he is procurator').

  2. 12.6.23.1quod ob talem transactionem solutum est

    A noun clause introduced by the relative pronoun quod, serving as the subject of the passive infinitive phrase retineri ... atque compensari ... potest used impersonally.

  3. 12.6.23.3post secuti

    The masculine singular genitive of the perfect participle secutus (from sequor), modified by the adverb post and agreeing with the preceding noun doli ('of fraud that followed afterwards'). Combined with exceptione doli, it refers to the 'plea of subsequent fraud' (exceptio doli post secuti).

  4. 12.6.23.3expertus

    The nominative singular masculine perfect participle of the deponent verb experior ('to try by law, sue'), modifying the subject relative pronoun qui, indicating that the party has initiated legal action contrary to the compromise.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · Revisions to the English translation and the original (3, latest 2026-11-15)
  • 2026-11-15 AI review — note 1
  • 2026-11-15 AI review — translation 1
  • 2026-09-22 AI review — source 1
urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:12.6.23.pr-12.6.23.4