← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§12.3.4.pr-12.3.4.4

Parties Bound to Swear and Judicial Discretion in Guardianship

After clarifying who is eligible to take the oath in actions concerning guardianship and curatorship, this section discusses the judge's power to set a maximum limit, his discretion after the oath, and the exclusion of the oath in cases of mere negligence.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[IDEM libro trigesimo sexto ad edictum.]

[THE SAME, Thirty-sixth Book on the Edict.]

§12.3.4.pr

​Uideamus in tutelari causa quis iurare et aduersus quem possit. et quidem ipse pupillus, si impubes est, non potest: hoc enim saepissime rescriptum est. sed nec tutorem cogendum uel matrem pupilli admittendam, etsi parata esset iurare, diui fratres rescripserunt:1 graue enim uidebatur et ignorantes et inuitos tutores sub alieni compendii emolumento etiam periurium anceps subire.2 curatores quoque pupilli uel adulescentis non esse cogendos in litem iurare rescriptis imperatoris nostri et diui patris eius continetur. si tamen tantam affectionem pupillo suo uel adulescenti tutores uel curatores praestare uolunt, auctoritas iuris non refragabitur, quin iudicio, quod inter ipsos acceptum est, finis eiusmodi possit adhiberi. non enim ad suam utilitatem iurisiurandi referenda aestimatio est, sed ad domini, cuius nomine tutelae ratio postulatur. adulescens uero si uelit iurare potest.

​Let us see who can swear, and against whom, in an action concerning guardianship. And indeed, the ward himself, if he is below the age of puberty, cannot; for this has very frequently been stated in rescripts. But the deified brothers also replied by rescript that neither should a tutor be compelled, nor should the ward’s mother be admitted, even if she were ready to swear; for it seemed harsh that tutors, who are ignorant and unwilling, should undergo even the hazard of perjury for the sake of another’s gain. It is also contained in the rescripts of our Emperor and of his deified father that curators of a ward or of a youth are not to be compelled to swear in court. If, however, tutors or curators wish to display such affection toward their ward or youth, the authority of the law will not oppose that such an end be put to the trial which has been accepted between them. For the valuation of the oath is not to be referred to their own benefit, but to that of the owner in whose name the account of the guardianship is demanded. But a youth, if he wishes, can swear.

§12.3.4.1

​Deferre autem iusiurandum iudicem oportet: ceterum si alius detulerit iusiurandum uel non delato iuratum sit, nulla erit religio nec ullum iusiurandum: et ita constitutionibus expressum est imperatoris nostri et diui patris eius.

​Moreover, the judge ought to tender the oath; but if someone else tenders the oath, or if the oath is taken without it being tendered, there will be no binding obligation nor any oath; and this is expressly stated in the constitutions of our Emperor and of his deified father.

§12.3.4.2

​Iurare autem in infinitum licet. sed an iudex modum iuriiurando statuere possit, ut intra certam quantitatem iuretur, ne arrepta occasione in immensum iuretur, quaero. et quidem in arbitrio esse iudicis deferre iusiurandum nec ne constat: an igitur qui possit iusiurandum non deferre, idem possit et taxationem iuriiurando adicere, quaeritur:3 arbitrio tamen bonae fidei iudicis etiam hoc congruit.

​Moreover, it is permitted to swear without limit. But I ask whether the judge can set a limit to the oath, so that the oath may be taken within a certain quantity, lest, the opportunity being seized, the oath be taken to an immeasurable amount. And indeed, it is established that it is within the discretion of the judge whether to tender the oath or not; it is therefore asked whether he who can refuse to tender the oath can also add a limitation to the oath: Yet this also is consistent with the discretion of a good faith judge.

§12.3.4.3

​Item uidendum, an possit iudex, qui detulit iusiurandum, non sequi id, sed uel prorsus absoluere uel etiam minoris condemnare quam iuratum est: et magis est, ut ex magna causa et postea repertis probationibus possit.

​Likewise, it must be considered whether a judge who has tendered the oath can choose not to follow it, but either to acquit entirely or to condemn for a lesser amount than was sworn to; and the better opinion is that he can do so for a great cause and if proofs are discovered later.

§12.3.4.4

​Ex culpa autem non esse iusiurandum deferendum constat, sed aestimationem a iudice faciendam.

​Furthermore, it is established that where there is mere negligence, the oath is not to be tendered, but the valuation must be made by the judge.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 12.3.4.prsed nec tutorem cogendum uel matrem pupilli admittendam, etsi parata esset iurare, diui fratres rescripserunt

    The verb rescripserunt governs an accusative and infinitive construction (indirect speech), in which esse is omitted after both cogendum and admittendam. tutorem is the subject accusative of cogendum [esse], and matrem is the subject accusative of admittendam [esse].

  2. 12.3.4.prgraue enim uidebatur et ignorantes et inuitos tutores sub alieni compendii emolumento etiam periurium anceps subire

    The entire infinitive clause with subire and its subject accusative tutores functions as the subject of the impersonal verb uidebatur ("it seemed"). et ignorantes et inuitos modifies tutores.

  3. 12.3.4.2an igitur qui possit iusiurandum non deferre, idem possit et taxationem iuriiurando adicere, quaeritur

    The impersonal passive verb quaeritur ("it is asked") governs the indirect question introduced by an. The relative clause qui possit... modifies idem, which is the subject of possit in the indirect question.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · Revisions to the English translation and the original (1, latest 2026-11-15)
  • 2026-11-15 AI review — translation 1
urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:12.3.4.pr-12.3.4.4