← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§12.2.31.pr

Discovery of New Evidence and Retrial After Oath

Gaius explains that even after an oath is taken, imperial constitutions may allow a case to be retried if new documents are found, but this applies only to judicial acquittals and not to out-of-court settlements made by oath between the parties.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[GAIUS libro trigensimo ad edictum prouinciale.]

[GAIUS, Book XXX on the Provincial Edict.]

§12.2.31.pr

​Admonendi sumus interdum etiam post iusiurandum exactum1 permitti constitutionibus principum ex integro causam agere, si quis noua instrumenta se inuenisse dicat, quibus nunc solis usurus sit.2 sed hae constitutiones tunc uidentur locum habere, cum a iudice aliquis absolutus fuerit (solent enim saepe iudices in dubiis causis exacto iureiurando secundum eum iudicare qui iurauerit): quod si3 alias inter ipsos iureiurando transactum sit negotium, non conceditur eandem causam retractare.

​We must be reminded that sometimes, even after an oath has been exacted, it is permitted by imperial constitutions to try the case anew, if anyone should say that he has found new documents, which alone he will now use. But these constitutions seem to apply only when someone has been acquitted by a judge (for in doubtful cases judges are often accustomed, after an oath has been exacted, to judge in favor of the person who has sworn); but if, on the other hand, the transaction was settled between the parties themselves by an oath, it is not permitted to reopen the same case.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 12.2.31.prpost iusiurandum exactum

    The perfect participle exactum modifies the noun iusiurandum in a dominant sense ("after the exaction of the oath"), a construction analogous to ab urbe condita.

  2. 12.2.31.prquibus nunc solis usurus sit

    The relative pronoun quibus is in the ablative case, governed by the verb uti (here as the active future participle usurus). usurus sit is a periphrastic conjugation (active future participle + subjunctive present of esse) expressing intention ("intends to use") within a subordinate clause of indirect speech introduced by dicat.

  3. 12.2.31.prquod si

    A combination of the transitional relative quod at the beginning of the sentence and the conditional conjunction si, introducing an adversative or transitional conditional clause ("but if", "on the other hand, if").

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · No revisions to the English translation or the originalurn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:12.2.31.pr