← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§12.1.42.pr-12.1.42.1

Guaranty for Deficit and Stipulation to Arrange Payment

This passage discusses the scope of liability and discharge in consecutive stipulations with a principal debtor and a guarantor for the deficit, as well as the restriction on maintaining an action when the stipulation is for "arranging payment."

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[CELSUS libro sexto digestorum.]

[CELSUS, from the sixth book of Digests.]

§12.1.42.pr

​Si ego decem stipulatus a Titio deinceps stipuler a Seio, quanto minus a Titio consequi possim:1 si decem petiero a Titio, non liberatur Seius, alioquin nequicquam mihi cauetur: at si iudicatum fecerit Titius, nihil ultra Seius tenebitur. sed si cum Seio egero, quantumcumque est quo minus a Titio exigere potuero eo tempore, quo iudicium inter me et Seium acceptum est,2 tanto minus a Titio postea petere possum.

​If I, having stipulated for ten from Titius, should then stipulate from Seius for whatever less I might be able to recover from Titius: if I sue Titius for ten, Seius is not released, otherwise my security would be in vain. But if Titius satisfies the judgment, Seius will be liable for nothing further. However, if I sue Seius, whatever is the amount by which I was unable to recover from Titius at the time when the joinder of issue was accepted between me and Seius, by so much less can I afterwards sue Titius.

§12.1.42.1

​Labeo ait, cum decem dari curari3 stipulatus sis, ideo non posse te decem dare oportere intendere, quia etiam reum locupletiorem dando promissor liberari possit: quo scilicet significat non esse cogendum eum accipere iudicium,4 si reum locupletem offerat.

​Labeo says that when you have stipulated for “ten to be taken care of to be given,” you cannot therefore maintain that “he ought to give ten,” because the promisor can be released even by providing a more solvent debtor. By this, of course, he means that the promisor is not to be compelled to accept a trial if the promisor offers a solvent debtor.

Syntax notes4 items
  1. 12.1.42.prquanto minus a Titio consequi possim

    A relative clause acting as the object of the verb stipuler, meaning "by how much less I might be able to recover from Titius" (i.e., the deficit). quanto is an ablative of degree of difference, which together with minus functions adverbially, making the whole clause represent the quantity of the deficit.

  2. 12.1.42.priudicium inter me et Seium acceptum est

    A technical legal expression in Roman law. iudicium accipere refers to accepting the formula and agreeing to trial, i.e., "joinder of issue" (litis contestatio). Here used in the passive voice, it designates the specific moment in time when the legal proceedings were formally established between the plaintiff and the defendant.

  3. 12.1.42.1decem dari curari

    The juxtaposition of two passive infinitives, dari (to be given) and curari (to be cared for/arranged), representing an indirect obligation to "arrange for ten to be paid." This is distinguished from a direct obligation to "give ten" (decem dare), leaving room for alternative methods of performance, such as providing a guarantor.

  4. 12.1.42.1non esse cogendum eum accipere iudicium

    An impersonal construction or accusative with infinitive clause with the gerundive cogendum [esse], where the subject accusative eum refers to the promisor (debtor). It means that the promisor is not to be forced to submit to trial (accept the formula as defendant) if the latter has already offered a solvent third-party debtor.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · Revisions to the English translation and the original (3, latest 2026-11-15)
  • 2026-11-15 AI review — translation 1
  • 2026-09-21 AI review — note 1
  • 2026-09-21 AI review — translation 1
urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:12.1.42.pr-12.1.42.1