- Source
- Digesta Iustiniani Augusti. Mommsen, Theodor & Krueger, Paul, editors. Berlin: Weidmann, 1870.
- Translation
- AI-generated (gemini-3.5-flash) — machine translation; may contain errors
- Languages
- 日本語 · English · 简体中文 · 한국어
- CTS URN
- urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:12.1.32.pr
- Generated
- Humanitext Reader · reader.humanitext.ai · 2026-11-17
On the question of whether a loan is contracted through a promise of payment based on a mistaken belief, Celsus decides that while no contract is formed, the recipient is obligated to return the money based on equity.
[CELSUS libro quinto digestorum.]
[CELSUS, from the fifth book of the Digests.]
Si et me et Titium mutuam pecuniam rogaueris et ego meum debitorem tibi promittere iusserim, tu stipulatus sis, cum putares eum Titii debitorem esse, an mihi obligaris?1 subsisto,2 si quidem nullum negotium mecum contraxisti: sed propius est ut3 obligari te existimem, non quia4 pecuniam tibi credidi (hoc enim nisi inter consentientes fieri non potest): sed quia pecunia mea ad te peruenit, eam mihi a te reddi bonum et aequum est.
If you have asked both me and Titius for a loan of money, and I have ordered my debtor to promise it to you, and you have stipulated with him, thinking that he was the debtor of Titius, are you obligated to me? I hesitate, since indeed you have contracted no business with me; but it is more correct that I should think you are obligated, not because I have lent you the money (for this cannot take place except between consenting parties), but because my money has come to you, and it is good and equitable that it be returned to me by you.
- 12.1.32.pran mihi obligaris
The particle an is used here to introduce a direct question. While an typically introduces the second alternative of a disjunctive question, here it emphatically introduces the question ("are you then obligated to me?") following the complex hypothetical scenario. obligaris is the second-person singular present passive of the first-conjugation verb obligare.
- 12.1.32.prsubsisto
A verb meaning "I halt" or "I hesitate." The jurist Celsus expresses his hesitation between the strict legal form (no contract is formed due to the lack of agreement) and the requirement of equity.
- 12.1.32.prpropius est ut
An impersonal expression using the adjective propius (neuter comparative of prope, "near"), meaning "it is closer (to the truth)" or "it is more reasonable that..." The verb existimem in the clause introduced by ut is in the present subjunctive first-person singular.
- 12.1.32.prnon quia ... sed quia
Two clauses introduced by quia expressing reason are contrasted. Although the subjunctive is often used for a rejected reason (non quia) to show it is a mere hypothetical assumption, here the indicative (credidi) is used to emphasize the objective fact that no loan was actually contracted.
