← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§10.2.8.pr-10.2.8.2

Pre-bequests of Accounts and Status of Semi-wild Animals

Ulpian discusses the procedures and security required when delivering pre-bequeathed accounts or accountant slaves, and addresses whether animals with homing instincts (doves and bees) or livestock captured by wild beasts fall within the action for dividing an inheritance.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[ULPIANUS libro nono decimo ad edictum.]

[ULPIANUS, On the Edict, book 19]

§10.2.8.pr

​Pomponius scribit, si uni ex heredibus praelegatae fuerint rationes, non prius ei tradendas, quam1 coheredes descripserint. nam et si seruus actor, inquit, fuerit legatus, non alias eum tradendum, quam rationes reddiderit. nos uidebimus, numquid et cautio sit interponenda, ut, quotiens desideratae fuerint rationes uel actor praelegatus, copia eorum fiat? plerumque enim authenticae rationes sunt necessariae actori2 ad instruenda ea, quae postea emergunt ad notitiam eius spectantia. et necessarium est cautionem ab eo super hoc coheredibus praestari.

​Pomponius writes that if accounts are pre-bequeathed to one of the heirs, they must not be delivered to him before the coheirs have copied them. For he says that even if a slave accountant is bequeathed, he must not be delivered otherwise than when he has rendered accounts. We shall see whether security must also be provided so that, whenever the accounts or the pre-bequeathed accountant are required, access to them may be provided. For generally original accounts are necessary for the accountant to prepare those matters which subsequently arise concerning his department. And it is necessary that security be furnished by him to the coheirs concerning this.

§10.2.8.1

​Idem Pomponius ait columbas, quae emitti solent de columbario, uenire in familiae herciscundae iudicium, cum nostrae sint tamdiu, quamdiu consuetudinem habeant ad nos reuertendi: quare si quis eas adpraehendisset, furti nobis competit actio. idem et in apibus dicitur, quia in patrimonio nostro computantur.

​The same Pomponius says that doves which are accustomed to be let fly from a dovecote come into the action for the division of an inheritance, since they are ours as long as they have the habit of returning to us; wherefore if anyone should capture them, the action for theft is available to us. The same is said also in the case of bees, because they are reckoned in our patrimony.

§10.2.8.2

​Sed et si quid de pecoribus nostris a bestia ereptum sit, uenire in familiae erciscundae iudicium putat, si feram euaserit: nam magis esse, ut3 non desinat nostrum esse, inquit, quod a lupo eripitur uel alia bestia, tamdiu, quamdiu ab eo non fuerit consumptum.

​But he also thinks that if anything from our cattle has been snatched by a beast, it comes into the action for the division of an inheritance if it should escape the wild beast; for he says that the better view is that what is snatched by a wolf or another beast does not cease to be ours as long as it has not been consumed by it.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 10.2.8.prnon prius... quam

    In the non prius... quam... construction expressing the condition for delivering pre-bequeathed accounts, tradendas [esse] (must be delivered) denotes a legal obligation within the process of partition of inheritance to protect the coheirs' interests, rather than a mere contractual duty.

  2. 10.2.8.practori

    The dative actori refers to the seruus actor (the slave accountant) mentioned just before. Although actor can mean 'plaintiff' in legal contexts, the subsequent phrase notitiam eius (his department/sphere of duty) makes it more natural to interpret this as a reference to the slave accountant's professional need to perform subsequent administrative tasks.

  3. 10.2.8.2nam magis esse, ut

    An elliptical expression where a word like opinandum or uerum is omitted from magis esse ('it is more reasonable/correct'), indicating a doctrinal preference. The ut clause introduces the substantive content of this opinion.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · No revisions to the English translation or the originalurn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:10.2.8.pr-10.2.8.2