← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§10.2.38.pr

Division of Inheritance and Revenues Within One's Share

Paulus responds to a query regarding the division of patrimony between an emancipated brother and sister, stating that no action lies against the brother if he did not receive more than his hereditary share from common revenues or decreed maintenance.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[PAULUS libro tertio responsorum.]

[PAULUS, from the third book of Responses.]

§10.2.38.pr

​Lucius et Titia fratres emancipati a patre adulti1 curatores acceperunt: hi communes pecunias ex reditibus redactas singulis subministrauerunt: postea omne patrimonium diuiserunt: et post diuisionem Titia soror Lucio fratri suo coepit quaestionem mouere, quasi amplius accepisset quam ipsa acceperat. cum Lucius frater eius non amplius sua portione,2 immo minus quam dimidiam consecutus sit, quaero, an Titiae competat aduersus fratrem actio. Paulus respondit, secundum ea quae proponuntur si Lucius non amplius ex reditu praediorum communium accepit, quam pro hereditaria portione ei competeret, nullam sorori eius aduersus eum competere actionem. idem respondit, cum ex decretis alimentis a praetore amplius fratrem accepisse diceretur quam sororem, non tamen ultra partem dimidiam.3

​Lucius and Titia, a brother and sister emancipated by their father, on reaching majority, received curators; these supplied to each of them common moneys realized from the revenues. Afterwards they divided the whole patrimony; and after the division, the sister Titia began to raise a dispute against her brother Lucius, as if he had received more than she herself had received. Since her brother Lucius obtained no more than his own share, but rather less than a half, I ask whether Titia has an action against her brother. Paulus answered that, according to the facts presented, if Lucius did not receive more from the revenue of the common estates than what would be due to him in proportion to his hereditary share, no action is available to his sister against him. He also answered that the same applies even though the brother was said to have received more than the sister from the maintenance decreed by the praetor, provided it was not, however, beyond a half share.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 10.2.38.pradulti

    A nominative plural masculine adjective modifying the subject 'Lucius et Titia fratres', indicating that they have reached the age of majority where they require curators.

  2. 10.2.38.prsua portione

    An ablative of comparison governed by the comparative 'amplius', meaning 'than his own share'.

  3. 10.2.38.prnon tamen ultra partem dimidiam

    An elliptical expression presupposing the conclusion of the preceding answer (nullam competere actionem). It implies that even if the brother received more from the decreed maintenance, 'provided however it was not beyond a half share' (no action is available).

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · Revisions to the English translation and the original (1, latest 2026-09-21)
  • 2026-09-21 AI review — note 1
urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:10.2.38.pr