← Livy

History of Rome

§28.24.1-28.24.16

Rumors of Scipio's Illness and Mutiny at Sucro

As rumors of Scipio's critical illness agitate Spain, allied leaders revolt and discipline collapses in the Roman camp at Sucro, culminating in a full-scale mutiny where the soldiers elect their own commanders.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →
§28.24.1

​Scipio ipse gravi morbo implicitus, graviore tamen fama,1 cum ad id quisque quod audierat insita hominibus libidine alendi de industria rumores adiceret aliquid, provinciam omnem ac maxime longinqua eius turbavit;

​Scipio himself was afflicted with a serious illness, but the rumor was even more serious, since everyone added something to what they had heard out of an innate human desire to intentionally nurture rumors, which disturbed the whole province and especially its distant parts;

§28.24.2

​apparuitque, quantam excitatura molem vera fuisset clades,2 cum vanus rumor tantas procellas excivisset. non socii in fide, non exercitus in officio mansit.

​and it became apparent how great a commotion a real disaster would have excited, since an empty rumor had stirred up such great tempests. Neither did the allies remain in their allegiance, nor the army in their duty.

§28.24.3

​Mandonius et Indibilis,3 quibus, quia regnum sibi Hispaniae pulsis inde Carthaginiensibus destinarant animis, ​nihil pro spe contigerat, concitatis popularibus — Lacetani autem erant — et iuventute Celtiberorum excita agrum Suessetanum Sedetanumque sociorum populi Romani hostiliter depopulati sunt. civilis alius furor in castris ad Sucronem ortus.

​Mandonius and Indibilis, for whom—because they had destined in their minds the kingdom of Spain for themselves once the Carthaginians were driven out thence— ​nothing had happened according to their hope, having stirred up their countrymen—who were Lacetani—and having excited the youth of the Celtiberians, hostilely ravaged the Suessetanian and Sedetanian territory of the allies of the Roman people. Another civil madness arose in the camp at Sucro.

§28.24.5

​octo ibi milia militum erant, praesidium gentibus, quae cis Hiberum incolunt, inpositum.

​There were eight thousand soldiers there, placed as a garrison for the nations that inhabit this side of the Ebro.

§28.24.6

​motae autem eorum mentes sunt non tum primum, cum de vita imperatoris dubii rumores allati sunt, sed iam ante licentia ex diutino, ut fit, otio conlecta, et non nihil, quod in hostico laxius rapto suetis4 vivere artiores in pace res erant.

​Now their minds were disturbed not then for the first time, when doubtful rumors about the commander’s life were brought, but already before by the license gathered from prolonged idleness, as usually happens, and not a little because, for those accustomed to live more loosely on plunder in enemy territory, conditions in peace were more restricted.

§28.24.7

​ac primo sermones tantum occulti serebantur: si bellum in provincia esset, quid sese inter pacatos facere? si debellatum iam et confecta provincia esset, cur in Italiam non revehi?

​And at first only secret conversations were spread: if there were war in the province, what were they doing among pacified peoples? If the war was already finished and the province subdued, why were they not being carried back to Italy?

§28.24.8

​flagitatum quoque stipendium procacius quam ex more et modestia militari erat, et ab custodibus probra in circumeuntes vigilias tribunos iacta, et noctu quidam praedatum in agrum circa pacatum ierant; postremo interdiu ac propalam sine commeatu ab signis abibant.

​Demands were also made for pay more insolently than was according to military custom and modesty, and insults were thrown by the guards at the tribunes patrolling the watches, and by night some had gone to plunder into the surrounding pacified territory; finally, by day and openly, they departed from the standards without leave.

§28.24.9

​omnia libidine ac licentia militum, nihil instituto ac disciplina militiae aut imperio eorum, qui praeerant, gerebatur.

​Everything was conducted according to the desire and license of the soldiers, nothing according to the institution and discipline of military service or the command of those who were in charge.

§28.24.10

​forma tamen Romanorum castrorum constabat una ea re, quod tribunos, ex contagione furoris haud expertes seditionis defectionisque rati5 fore, et iura reddere in principiis sinebant et signum ab eis petebant et in stationes ac vigilias ordine ibant;

​Yet the form of a Roman camp was maintained by this one thing: that, because they thought the tribunes, from the contagion of their madness, would not be free from sedition and defection, they both allowed them to administer justice in the headquarters, and sought the watchword from them, and went on guard and watch in order;

§28.24.11

​et ut vim imperii abstulerant, ita speciem dicto parentium,6 ultro ipsi imperantes, servabant.

​and while they had taken away the force of authority, they nevertheless preserved the appearance of those obeying a command, they themselves actually commanding.

§28.24.12

​erupit deinde seditio, postquam reprehendere atque inprobare tribunos ea, quae fierent, et conari obviam ire et propalam abnuere furoris eorum se futuros socios senserunt.

​The mutiny then broke out, after they perceived that the tribunes were censuring and disapproving of what was being done, and trying to oppose it, and openly refusing that they would be associates in their madness.

§28.24.13

​fugatis itaque e principiis ac post paulo e castris tribunis, ad principes seditionis, gregarios milites, C. Albium Calenum et C. Atrium Umbrum, delatum omnium consensu imperium est.

​Therefore, the tribunes having been driven from the headquarters and shortly after from the camp, the command was conferred by the consensus of all upon the leaders of the sedition, common soldiers, Gaius Albius Calenus and Gaius Atrius Umber.

§28.24.14

​qui nequaquam tribuniciis contenti ornamentis insignia etiam summi imperii, fasces securesque, attrectare ausi; neque venit in mentem suis tergis suisque cervicibus virgas illas securesque imminere, quas ad metum aliorum praeferrent.

​Who, by no means content with the ornaments of a tribune, even dared to touch the insignia of supreme command, the fasces and axes; nor did it enter their minds that those rods and axes, which they carried before them to the terror of others, were hanging over their own backs and necks.

§28.24.15

​mors Scipionis falso credita obcaecabat animos, sub cuius vulgatam mox famam non dubitabant totam Hispaniam arsuram bello;

​The falsely believed death of Scipio blinded their minds, under the soon-to-be-spread rumor of which they did not doubt that all Spain would burn with war;

§28.24.16

​in eo tumultu et sociis pecunias imperari et diripi propinquas urbes posse, et turbatis rebus, cum omnia omnes auderent, minus insignia fore, quae ipsi fecissent.

​in that tumult both money could be demanded from the allies and nearby cities plundered, and in the disturbed state of affairs, since everyone would dare everything, the things they themselves had done would be less conspicuous.

Syntax notes6 items
  1. 28.24.1graviore tamen fama

    Ablative of comparison contrasting with the preceding gravi morbo, indicating that the rumor (fama) was even more serious and damaging than the actual illness.

  2. 28.24.2quantam excitatura molem vera fuisset clades

    The subjunctive pluperfect of the active periphrastic conjugation (excitatura fuisset), representing the apodosis of an unreal condition (conjunctivus irrealis) in an indirect question.

  3. 28.24.3Mandonius et Indibilis

    Grammatically the subject of the sentence, which is separated from its main verb depopulati sunt in §28.24.4 by several intervening relative clauses, participles, and ablative absolutes.

  4. 28.24.6suetis

    A perfect participle agreeing with the omitted militibus. It functions as the dative of reference/interest with res erant artiores, acting as the logical subject of vivere.

  5. 28.24.10rati

    Perfect participle of the deponent verb reor, agreeing with the subject (the soldiers) and introducing the accusative and infinitive construction (tribunos ... fore...).

  6. 28.24.11speciem dicto parentiun

    Derived from the phrase dicto parere (to obey a command). The genitive plural parentium of the present participle parens modifies dicto, meaning 'the appearance of those obeying a command.'

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-05-25) · Revision history (3, latest 2026-09-22)
  • 2026-09-22 AI review — source 1
  • 2026-09-21 AI review — source 1
  • 2026-09-21 AI review — translation 1
urn:cts:latinLit:phi0914.phi001.humanitext-lat2:28.24.1-28.24.16