← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§9.2.40.pr

Destruction of Bond of Conditional Debt Before Fulfillment

Explains that if a written acknowledgment of a conditional debt is destroyed, the creditor can win an action under the Lex Aquilia even before the condition is fulfilled if there is a risk that witnesses might not be available later, though the execution of the judgment is suspended until the condition is actually fulfilled.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[PAULUS libro tertio ad edictum.]

[PAULUS, in the third book on the Edict.]

§9.2.40.pr

​In lege Aquilia, si deletum chirographum mihi esse1 dicam, in quo sub condicione mihi pecunia debita fuerit, et interim testibus quoque id probare possim, qui testes possunt non esse eo tempore, quo condicio extitit, et si summatim re exposita ad suspicionem iudicem adducam, debeam uincere:2 sed tunc condemnationis exactio competit, cum debiti condicio extiterit: quod si defecerit,3 condemnatio nullas uires habebit.

​Under the Lex Aquilia, if I should claim that a written acknowledgment of debt, in which money was owed to me under a condition, has been destroyed to my detriment, and in the meantime I am also able to prove this by witnesses, which witnesses may not be available at the time when the condition is fulfilled, and if, having explained the matter in outline, I bring the judge to a suspicion, I ought to win. But the execution of the condemnation is competent only when the condition of the debt has been fulfilled; and if this fails, the condemnation will have no force.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 9.2.40.prdeletum chirographum mihi esse

    An accusative-with-infinitive construction (accusative chirographum + infinitive esse + perfect participle deletum in the passive voice) governed by dicam (I claim). mihi is a dative of disadvantage or interest ("to my detriment" or "against me" as the creditor whose document was destroyed).

  2. 9.2.40.prsi deletum chirographum mihi esse dicam ... et interim testibus quoque id probare possim ... et si summatim re exposita ad suspicionem iudicem adducam, debeam uincere

    A conditional sentence using the present subjunctive (future less vivid or hypothetical condition). The protasis (si dicam... et... possim... et si... adducam) corresponds to the apodosis (debeam uincere), also in the present subjunctive, expressing potentiality or propriety: "if I should claim... I ought to win."

  3. 9.2.40.prquod si defecerit

    quod si (quodsi) is a connecting conjunctional phrase (literally adverbial accusative quod + si, meaning "but if"), with condicio (feminine) from the preceding clause as the implicit subject of defecerit. defecerit is the future perfect indicative (or perfect subjunctive) of the intransitive verb deficio (to fail, not to occur), expressing a future hypothesis of the condition's failure.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · Revision history (1, latest 2026-11-15)
  • 2026-11-15 AI review — note 1
urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:9.2.40.pr