← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§9.2.22.pr-9.2.22.1

Depreciation of Paired Items and Promised Slaves

The jurist discusses the inclusion of lost interest in actions involving the killing of a slave promised for delivery under penalty, and the valuation of depreciation when one member of a collective group (like actors, teams, or pairs) is killed.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[PAULUS libro uicensimo secundo ad edictum.]

[PAULUS, from the twenty-second book on the Edict.]

§9.2.22.pr

​Proinde si seruum occidisti, quem sub poena tradendum promisi, utilitas1 uenit in hoc iudicium.

​Therefore, if you killed a slave whom I had promised to deliver under penalty, my interest comes into this action.

§9.2.22.1

​Item causae corpori cohaerentes2 aestimantur, si quis ex comoedis aut symphoniacis aut gemellis aut quadriga aut ex pari mularum unum uel unam occiderit: non solum enim perempti corporis aestimatio facienda est, sed et eius ratio haberi debet, quo3 cetera corpora depretiata sunt.

​Likewise, those circumstances that are linked to the body are valued, if someone kills one (male or female) from a group of comedic actors, musicians, twins, a four-horse chariot, or a pair of mules: for not only must a valuation be made of the body that was destroyed, but account must also be taken of the amount by which the remaining bodies have depreciated.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 9.2.22.prutilitas

    "Interest" or "utility." Here it is synonymous with eius quod interest (the substantial interest, including lost profits) mentioned in the previous section (§9.2.21.2), indicating that the concrete damage, such as the risk of paying a penalty for breach of contract, is subject to valuation.

  2. 9.2.22.1causae corpori cohaerentes

    Literally "circumstances adhering to the body." It refers not merely to the physical value of an individual slave or animal as a single unit, but to the accessory and external factors of value that arise when they function together as a group (such as members of a theatrical troupe or a pair of animals).

  3. 9.2.22.1quo

    Ablative of the relative pronoun, functioning either as an ablative of degree/measure of difference, or as an ablative of means/cause. It is construed with eius ("of that [amount/extent] by which the remaining bodies have depreciated") or as "of the fact that by this the other bodies were depreciated," indicating that the reduction in value of the remaining units must be taken into account.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12)urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:9.2.22.pr-9.2.22.1