← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§7.4.17.pr

Conditional Bequest of Ownership and Extinction of Usufruct

This section explains that when a usufruct is unconditionally bequeathed to one person and the ownership is conditionally bequeathed to another, if the first person acquires the ownership before the condition is fulfilled, the other person will eventually obtain full ownership of the land upon the fulfillment of the condition.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[IULIANUS libro tricensimo quinto digestorum.]

[JULIANUS in the thirty-fifth book of the Digests.]

§7.4.17.pr

​Si tibi fundi usus fructus pure, proprietatem1 autem sub condicione Titio legata fuerit, pendente condicione dominium proprietatis adquisieris, deinde condicio extiterit, pleno iure fundum Titius habebit neque interest, quod detracto usu fructu2 proprietas legata sit: enim dum proprietatem adquiris, ius omne legati usus fructus amisisti.3

​If the usufruct of a tract of land is bequeathed to you unconditionally, but the ownership is bequeathed to Titius under a condition, and while the condition is pending you acquire the domain of the ownership, and then the condition is fulfilled, Titius will hold the land with full right; and it makes no difference that the ownership was bequeathed with the usufruct deducted: for while you acquire the ownership, you have lost all right of the bequeathed usufruct.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 7.4.17.prproprietatem

    Although the accusative proprietatem appears in the manuscripts, it functions as the subject of the feminine singular verb legata fuerit. It is standard to interpret it as if it were the nominative proprietas ("ownership").

  2. 7.4.17.prdetracto usu fructu

    An ablative absolute construction consisting of the ablative noun usu fructu and the perfect participle detracto, meaning "with the usufruct deducted" or "excluding the usufruct."

  3. 7.4.17.prdum proprietatem adquiris, ... amisisti

    The conjunction dum ("while") takes the present tense verb adquiris, combined with the perfect tense amisisti in the main clause. This is a standard Latin construction indicating that at the very moment of acquiring the ownership, the right to the usufruct was already lost.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12)urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:7.4.17.pr