← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§3.5.10.pr

Scope of Manager's Liability and Set-Off of Profit and Loss

This section defines the scope of liability for negligence and fraud in the unauthorized management of an absent person's affairs, details the exceptional liability for accidents when undertaking unfamiliar new businesses, and explains the offset of profits and losses across multiple transactions.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[POMPONIUS libro uicensimo primo ad Quintum Mucium.]

[POMPONIUS, on Quintus Mucius, book twenty-one]

§3.5.10.pr

​Si negotia absentis et ignorantis geras, et culpam et dolum praestare debes. sed Proculus interdum etiam casum praestare debere,1 ueluti si nouum negotium, quod non sit solitus absens facere, tu nomine eius geras: ueluti uenales nouicios coemendo uel aliquam negotiationem ineundo. nam si quid damnum ex ea re secutum fuerit, te sequetur, lucrum uero absentem:2 quod si in quibusdam lucrum factum fuerit, in quibusdam damnum, absens pensare3 lucrum cum damno debet.

​If you should manage the affairs of one who is absent and unaware, you must answer for both negligence and fraud. But Proculus thinks that sometimes one must even answer for accident, as for instance if you should manage in his name a new business which the absent person was not accustomed to do: for instance, by purchasing newly-imported slaves for sale or by entering into some trading business. For if any loss should result from that matter, it will fall upon you, but the profit indeed upon the absent person; but if profit should be made in some transactions and loss in others, the absent person must balance the profit against the loss.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 3.5.10.prdebere

    In the clause "Proculus interdum etiam casum praestare debere", the infinitive "debere" depends on an omitted verb of saying or thinking (such as "putat", "ait", or "scribit"). "Proculus" is the nominative subject of an omitted verb of saying or thinking (such as "putat", "ait", or "scribit"), while the subject accusative of the infinitive "debere" (referring to "te") is understood.

  2. 3.5.10.prabsentem

    In the phrase "lucrum uero absentem", the verb "sequetur" is omitted from the preceding clause "te sequetur". It should be understood as "lucrum uero absentem [sequetur]" (but profit indeed will follow the absent person).

  3. 3.5.10.prpensare

    The verb "pensare" originally means "to weigh", but is used here in the sense of "to balance" or "offset" (synonymous with "compensare") profit against loss.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · Revision history (1, latest 2026-09-21)
  • 2026-09-21 AI review — note 1
urn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:3.5.10.pr