← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§12.6.46.pr

Recovery of Undue Legacies Paid in the Heir's Name

This section discusses the right of recovery when an unauthorized payment of an undue legacy is made in the name of the heir using the heir's own money, clarifying the legal remedies available to the owner.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[IDEM libro quarto ex Plautio.]

[The same, in the fourth book on Plautius.]

§12.6.46.pr

​Qui heredis nomine legata non debita ex nummis ipsius heredis soluit, ipse quidem repetere non potest:1 sed si ignorante herede nummos eius tradidit, dominus, ait, eos recte uindicabit.2 eadem causa rerum corporalium est.3

​A person who, in the name of the heir, has paid legacies that are not due out of the money of the heir himself, cannot himself recover them; but if he delivered the money without the knowledge of the heir, the owner (the heir), he says, will rightfully claim it by a vindicatio. The same rule applies to corporeal things.

Syntax notes3 items
  1. 12.6.46.pripse quidem repetere non potest

    The reason why the payor himself (ipse) cannot bring a condictio for recovery is that the payment was made "in the name of the heir (heredis nomine)" and with the heir's money, meaning any potential claim belongs to the heir, and no personal claim arises for the actor.

  2. 12.6.46.prdominus, ait, eos recte uindicabit

    The subject of "ait" (he says) refers to Plautius, whom the author is commenting on. The owner (dominus, i.e., the heir) is said to have a claim by vindicatio (uindicabit) rather than a condictio because, since the money was delivered without the heir's consent, ownership did not pass, and thus a property-based claim (rei vindicatio) is applicable as long as the coins have not been mixed or spent.

  3. 12.6.46.preadem causa rerum corporalium est

    Although money (nummi) is physically a corporeal thing (res corporales), it is often treated separately in law because its ownership becomes difficult to trace once mixed or spent. This phrase confirms that the same principle applies to other corporeal things (such as specific movable property) delivered without authority, meaning the owner retains the right to bring a rei vindicatio.

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · No revisions to the English translation or the originalurn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:12.6.46.pr