← Justinian I

The Digest of Justinian

§11.1.14.pr-11.1.14.1

Invalidity of Confessions upon Status Rulings and Natural Law

This section discusses the effect of a confession when the person in question is judged to be free while the trial is pending, and establishes the principle that confessions are only valid if their content is compatible with both law and nature.

View ▾
View
Translation
Typeface
AI ↗
← PrevNext →

[IAUOLENUS libro nono ex Cassio.]

[JAVOLENUS, from the ninth book on Cassius.]

§11.1.14.pr

​Si is, cuius nomine noxae iudicium acceptum est, manente iudicio liber iudicatus est, reus absolui debet, nec quicquam interrogatio in iure facta proderit, quia eius personae, cuius nomine quis cum alio actionem habet, obligationem1 transferre potest in eum, qui in iure suum esse confitetur, uelut alienum seruum suum esse confitendo: liberi autem hominis nomine quia cum alio actio non est, ne per interrogationem quidem aut confessionem transferri poterit. quo casu eueniet, ut non recte hominis liberi nomine actum sit cum eo qui confessus est.

​If he, in whose name a noxal trial was undertaken, is adjudged free while the trial is pending, the defendant ought to be acquitted, nor will the interrogation conducted in court be of any avail; because one can transfer the liability of that person, in whose name someone has an action against another, to him who confesses in court that the person is his, for example, by confessing that another’s slave is his own; but because there is no action against another in the name of a free man, it cannot be transferred even by interrogation or confession. In which case it will result that the action in the name of a free man was not correctly brought against him who confessed.

§11.1.14.1

​In totum autem confessiones ita ratae sunt, si id, quod in confessionem uenit,2 et ius et naturam recipere potest.

​Generally, however, confessions are valid only if that which becomes the subject of the confession can admit both law and nature.

Syntax notes2 items
  1. 11.1.14.preius personae ... obligationem

    The genitive eius personae modifies the noun obligationem ("liability, obligation"), separated by the relative clause cuius nomine quis cum alio actionem habet. Thus, the syntax is structured as "can transfer (transferre potest) the liability (obligationem) of that person (eius personae) who... to him who...".

  2. 11.1.14.1id, quod in confessionem uenit

    A noun phrase functioning as the subject, literally meaning "that which comes into confession," i.e., "the matter which becomes the object or content of the confession."

Translated by Gemini 3.5 Flash (published 2026-07-12) · No revisions to the English translation or the originalurn:cts:latinLit:phi2806.phi002.humanitext-lat1:11.1.14.pr-11.1.14.1